Difference between revisions of "Usage-based Data Discovery - Episode 2"
From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
(4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
* Joe Lee | * Joe Lee | ||
* Irina Gerasimov | * Irina Gerasimov | ||
− | * Adrienne | + | * Adrienne Canino |
* Megan Carter | * Megan Carter | ||
* Ed Armstrong | * Ed Armstrong | ||
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
* Bob Downs | * Bob Downs | ||
* Beth Huffer | * Beth Huffer | ||
− | * | + | * Jonathan Blythe |
* Doug Newman | * Doug Newman | ||
* Steve Olding | * Steve Olding | ||
Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
** '''Best Practice Use Case:''' Which rainfall dataset is most often used for flood prediction? | ** '''Best Practice Use Case:''' Which rainfall dataset is most often used for flood prediction? | ||
** '''Impact Use Case:''' How many climate studies use TRMM 3B42 rainfall? | ** '''Impact Use Case:''' How many climate studies use TRMM 3B42 rainfall? | ||
− | ** | + | ** '''Congruency Use Case:''' Do field data, airborne lidar, and satellite data match (MAAP)? Do data from sensors on the same satellite match (TerraFusion)? |
* [[Sample graphs]] | * [[Sample graphs]] | ||
* Any other business? | * Any other business? | ||
Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
= Notes = | = Notes = | ||
+ | * Use Cases: Participating: Bob, Jonathon, Beth, Ed | ||
+ | |||
+ | == Best Practice Use Case == | ||
+ | * Ed: interested in interdisciplinary, datasets used together WITHIN a given application | ||
+ | * Mark: simple, single dataset use case + complex interdisciplinary use cases | ||
+ | * Beth: dataset interconnections circles back to data transformations | ||
+ | * Irina: validation requires MANY different datasets being used together, shows up in separate of research papers that focus on the application vs. those that focus on validation | ||
+ | * J.B.: discovery / search process: present datasets relevant to their problem, e.g., homeowner types in more colloquial term, interpret what the user's real concern is | ||
+ | * Adrienne (Axiom Data Science): how do we interact with users where they know what they are getting back; users expect fancy searches, but they need to be transparent (document how they got there) - show the graph! | ||
+ | * B. Downs: combine with location of interest | ||
+ | * JB: maybe too big a tech lift at this point? | ||
+ | * Mark: location is relevant, sure, but how does it | ||
+ | * Chris: dataset used Gulf of Maine, might be useful in Puget Sound | ||
+ | * Mark: identify desired outcome | ||
+ | |||
+ | == IMPACT Use Case == | ||
+ | * In addition to how many, what type of use cases | ||
+ | * Beth: Take me to the articles about the data | ||
+ | * Irina: Data providers want to know about applications of their data; ask them if they know how their data are being used | ||
+ | * Bob: What other data were used in conjunction with the datasets in a given climate study | ||
+ | * JB: datasets commonly used together (Mark: closer to Beth's use case variant) | ||
+ | * JB: IMPACT might be a roll up of lots of datasets | ||
+ | * Mark: may want to contrast similar instrument, different algorithms, (Chris: or different platforms) | ||
+ | * Ed: roll up by Societal Benefit Area | ||
+ | |||
+ | == Next Agenda == | ||
+ | * Irina, Beth more graphs, how to make them | ||
+ | * Adrienne: User story, aiming to create at the end | ||
+ | * Ed: Using graphs for discovery, esp. related datasets, practical examples | ||
+ | * Mark: Take one of these use cases, work a user story end to end to see what the graph looks like, including the tools | ||
+ | * Bob: examples of graphs, something about the process we are going through, getting from here to there | ||
+ | * Megan: Session proposal, ESIP Collaboration Slide | ||
= New Actions = | = New Actions = |
Latest revision as of 16:50, March 25, 2020
Participants
- Chris Lynnes
- Joe Lee
- Irina Gerasimov
- Adrienne Canino
- Megan Carter
- Ed Armstrong
- Mark Parsons
- Bob Downs
- Beth Huffer
- Jonathan Blythe
- Doug Newman
- Steve Olding
Current Actions
- Done: Lynnes - write up some text for Megan's newsletter
- Done: Lynnes set up regular meeting with ESIP G2M, some time other than 4th Thursday
- TBD - spin off a subgroup to work on use cases
- Done: Lynnes/Newman - generate a sample export of EOSDIS knowledge graph
- Done: Blythe - provide research_prov_model info on use of W3C Prov model
Agenda
- Use cases for connecting Data with Usage
- Best Practice Use Case: Which rainfall dataset is most often used for flood prediction?
- Impact Use Case: How many climate studies use TRMM 3B42 rainfall?
- Congruency Use Case: Do field data, airborne lidar, and satellite data match (MAAP)? Do data from sensors on the same satellite match (TerraFusion)?
- Sample graphs
- Any other business?
- Agenda for next telecon…
Notes
- Use Cases: Participating: Bob, Jonathon, Beth, Ed
Best Practice Use Case
- Ed: interested in interdisciplinary, datasets used together WITHIN a given application
- Mark: simple, single dataset use case + complex interdisciplinary use cases
- Beth: dataset interconnections circles back to data transformations
- Irina: validation requires MANY different datasets being used together, shows up in separate of research papers that focus on the application vs. those that focus on validation
- J.B.: discovery / search process: present datasets relevant to their problem, e.g., homeowner types in more colloquial term, interpret what the user's real concern is
- Adrienne (Axiom Data Science): how do we interact with users where they know what they are getting back; users expect fancy searches, but they need to be transparent (document how they got there) - show the graph!
- B. Downs: combine with location of interest
- JB: maybe too big a tech lift at this point?
- Mark: location is relevant, sure, but how does it
- Chris: dataset used Gulf of Maine, might be useful in Puget Sound
- Mark: identify desired outcome
IMPACT Use Case
- In addition to how many, what type of use cases
- Beth: Take me to the articles about the data
- Irina: Data providers want to know about applications of their data; ask them if they know how their data are being used
- Bob: What other data were used in conjunction with the datasets in a given climate study
- JB: datasets commonly used together (Mark: closer to Beth's use case variant)
- JB: IMPACT might be a roll up of lots of datasets
- Mark: may want to contrast similar instrument, different algorithms, (Chris: or different platforms)
- Ed: roll up by Societal Benefit Area
Next Agenda
- Irina, Beth more graphs, how to make them
- Adrienne: User story, aiming to create at the end
- Ed: Using graphs for discovery, esp. related datasets, practical examples
- Mark: Take one of these use cases, work a user story end to end to see what the graph looks like, including the tools
- Bob: examples of graphs, something about the process we are going through, getting from here to there
- Megan: Session proposal, ESIP Collaboration Slide