ISO Compliance Reports

From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
Revision as of 15:57, July 19, 2008 by Ted.Habermann (talk | contribs) (→‎Yes)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

How ISO Does It

Standards are critical for data understanding and sharing. The ISO Standard include three types of data quality reports. The first, the DQ_ConformanceResult, describes how the dataset was tested for conformance to a published standard and whether the dataset passed the test. The second, the DQ_QuantitativeResult, provides a mechanism for describing the results of a quantitative quality evaluation. Finally, the QE_CoverageResult (from ISO 19115-2), allows a quality result to be expressed as a spatial object. For example, if a gridded dataset has an associated grid of quality flags, that quality grid could be described here. Note also that the coverage results have an associated file and format.

DQ_ConformanceResult
+ specification : CI_Citation
+ explanation : CharacterString
+ pass : Boolean

ESIP Response

Yes

  • Ken Casey – at least we should
  • Karl Benedict - Compliance for delivery, also a quality attribute in terms of compliance OR variance vs. standards
  • Ed Armstrong But only to point we are making valid XML records etc.
  • Rudy Husar
  • Henry
  • Jeff Arnfield – Yes/No: - stds would be helpful in exchange of metadata and in its collection. No bonus points for compliance yet, though, since stds thus far have been only loosely and sporadically applied.