Revision as of 13:15, July 19, 2011

User Stories

Science Researcher (Kwo-Sen Kuo)
Science Assessment Panel (Brian Wee)
Novice Graduate Student (Chris Lynnes)

ESC Implementation Strategies

Key Questions and Ideas

Is 5-7 year time frame to build ESC too long?
How do we leverage other efforts in this area?
- NSF Earth Cube
- NASA Earth Exchange
- Virtual observatories
- International
More user stories would be helpful
- Project collaboration
- Recast novice grad student as an educational story?
Will scientists share?
- Some sharing is required by funding agencies, but...
- How to incentivize?
Suggest 4 main thrusts:

User Stories, both for outreach and guiding architecture and implementation
Cyberinfrastructure
Programmatic (how to get the agencies, including NSF, on the same page)
Sociological: the sociology of sharing and incentivization

ESC needs to become a more formal cluster, yes, with telecons, to prepare for the Winter meeting.
Raw Notes

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 * [[Media:NoviceGraduateStudentStory|Novice Graduate Student]] (Chris Lynnes)
 = [[ESC Implementation Strategies]] =
-= Important Feedback and Notes =
+=Key Questions and Ideas =
-* NSF Earth Cube looks a lot like ESC
+* Is 5-7 year time frame to build ESC too long?
-** But other agencies (i.e., federal employees) have difficulty directly working with NSF
+* How do we leverage other efforts in this area?
-* Frank (NASA): Is 5-7 Year time frame too long?
+** NSF Earth Cube
-** Chris: Progress and benefits will be incremental over that time
+** NASA Earth Exchange
-* Eric (NOAA): Some parts of ESC are pretty far along, e.g., virtual observatories, space data
+** Virtual observatories
-** Chris: Yes, these parts represent Prior Art in some cases, components that should be leveraged or incorporated in other cases
+** International
-* Kevin: primary qualities - develop trust, how do you share trust? (good question)
+* More user stories would be helpful
-* Chris M.: How do you incentivize participation?  Lots of portals being developed, scope the collaboratory within its funding.
+** Project collaboration
-* DataNet: how does data extend beyond the grant.  Now: how does the software extend beyond the grant? Open source, etc.?
+** Recast novice grad student as an educational story?
-* Paulo: Earth Science Domain Scenario for collaboratory.  Does the infrastructure have to be Earth Science specific?  Is funding more available to a more general approach (such as OCI)?
+* Will scientists share?
-** Chris: The ''stakeholders'' are domain specific, which is directly tied to the funding.
+** Some sharing is required by funding agencies, but...
+** How to incentivize?
+* Suggest 4 main thrusts:
+# User Stories, both for outreach and guiding architecture and implementation
+# Cyberinfrastructure
+# Programmatic (how to get the agencies, including NSF, on the same page)
+# Sociological:  the sociology of sharing and incentivization
+* ESC needs to become a more formal cluster, yes, with telecons, to prepare for the Winter meeting.
+* [[ESC_Summer_2011_Notes|Raw Notes]]

Difference between revisions of "ESC Cluster Meeting at ESIP 2011 Summer Meeting"

Revision as of 13:15, July 19, 2011

User Stories

ESC Implementation Strategies

Key Questions and Ideas