Difference between revisions of "Draft Excom Minutes"

From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
Line 14: Line 14:
 
# Committee Reports (All)
 
# Committee Reports (All)
 
#* Partnership - Tyler reported that the named a new Type III Rep, Gary Randolph from GLOBE. The committee has received a few new member applications and will meet next month to review them. Finally, Tyler has worked with Carol and Erin on ways to engage current members and ideas for new member welcome packet.  
 
#* Partnership - Tyler reported that the named a new Type III Rep, Gary Randolph from GLOBE. The committee has received a few new member applications and will meet next month to review them. Finally, Tyler has worked with Carol and Erin on ways to engage current members and ideas for new member welcome packet.  
#*Cross-ESIP coordination (Peter Fox)
 
#*Replacing Finance & Appropriations Chair
 
#**
 
 
#*Partnership and Finance Committee Members Needed (Gary Randolph, GLOBE has stepped forward for Partnership; Reagan Moore, DICE has stepped forward for Ficom)
 
#*Partnership and Finance Committee Members Needed (Gary Randolph, GLOBE has stepped forward for Partnership; Reagan Moore, DICE has stepped forward for Ficom)
 
#* Constitution & Bylaws - Bruce reported that the group met earlier this month to review past business and the committee is open to changes coming from 3 members. The group plans to look at how to clean-up long-term, inactive membership. The group would also like to move from a floating target % of active members to a numeric quorum. Peter brought up the idea of forming a new nomination committee, so that as the Federation grows and there are contested positions we have a process.  
 
#* Constitution & Bylaws - Bruce reported that the group met earlier this month to review past business and the committee is open to changes coming from 3 members. The group plans to look at how to clean-up long-term, inactive membership. The group would also like to move from a floating target % of active members to a numeric quorum. Peter brought up the idea of forming a new nomination committee, so that as the Federation grows and there are contested positions we have a process.  
Line 23: Line 20:
 
#* IT & I - Carol reported for Matt Austin that the group kicked off the year with Rich Signell giving the Rant/Rave on iPython Notebooks. Erin is working with Matt to identify future speakers for the series.  
 
#* IT & I - Carol reported for Matt Austin that the group kicked off the year with Rich Signell giving the Rant/Rave on iPython Notebooks. Erin is working with Matt to identify future speakers for the series.  
 
#* Products & Services - Christine reported that the group is meeting next week. She has reactivated the Testbed configuration board and together they have a 2014 Request for Testbed Proposals. This will be discussed at their first P&S meeting. Finally, the P&S Committee will look at FUNding Friday rules/criteria and update them.  
 
#* Products & Services - Christine reported that the group is meeting next week. She has reactivated the Testbed configuration board and together they have a 2014 Request for Testbed Proposals. This will be discussed at their first P&S meeting. Finally, the P&S Committee will look at FUNding Friday rules/criteria and update them.  
 +
#*Cross-ESIP coordination (Peter Fox) - Peter asked each of the chairs to think about the roles and responsibilities that co-chairs may take in the group this year. He suggested that one role may be to link across ESIP collaboration areas. Sara asked about the role that type reps might play and if there was any analysis on the type of activities. Erin took that as an action and will work with the type reps to answer some of those questions.
 +
#*Replacing Finance & Appropriations Chair
 +
#** Chuck Hutchinson served as both the Finance Committee chair for ESIP and the treasurer of the Foundation. When the Foundation bylaws were updated he could no longer serve on both and resigned his seat on the Foundation Board. Since that time, it's become clear that he's needed on the Foundation Board, so he resigned as FiCom Chair. Chuck worked with Carol and Peter to identify a replacement for ESIP and Bill Teng has stepped forward. There was no discussion from group on Bill. Sara moved to approve Bill as the chair of FiCom. Denise 2nded. Bill was approved by acclimation.
 +
#** There were two other committee seats that needed to be filled after the ESIP Winter Meeting. Christine motioned to accept Gary Randolph for Type III rep to Partnership and Reagan Moore as Type III Rep to Finance. Tyler 2nded. Both were approved by acclimation.
 
# Other Business
 
# Other Business
#* [http://www.icsu-wds.org/our-members/membership-application WDS Expression of Interest] - The group took an action to view
+
#* Sara asked if there are minutes from the ESIP Assembly Meeting. Carol will provide to the group.
#* Finding a New Time to Meet - [http://doodle.com/az7qu4xqwne2idds Doodle Poll]
+
#* Strategic Plan - Peter reported that ESIP is currently due to update its strategic plan. Emily Law will lead this effort.
 +
#* [http://www.icsu-wds.org/our-members/membership-application WDS Expression of Interest] - The group took an action for Erin to review the implications of WDS membership and report back to the group next month. Those familiar with WDS will support Erin.
 +
#* Finding a New Time to Meet - [http://doodle.com/az7qu4xqwne2idds Doodle Poll] - The current meeting time isn't available for Vice President Emily Law. Carol requested that the group respond to the doodle poll, so that we can find a new time.
  
# ESIP Meetings
+
The meeting adjourned at 2:09.
#*Looking Ahead to Winter 2014 - Program Development
 
#** Carol Meyer reported that the Winter Program is shaping up and today is the soft deadline for sessions. Registration is slow to get started, but we expect an uptick as we get closer to the meeting. The plenaries are shaping up. We have commitments from NOAA, USGS and NITRD to the Data Study Vision Panel on the first day. We are still waiting for NASA and looking for a DOE contact. We also have a speaker from Software Carpentry and we have an additional invitation extended. We will start the second day with business meeting and then follow with a panel on Open Data in Government and implementation challenges. A request was made to ExCom for pictures from ESIP pasts - please send to Erin. Jeff DLB is leading a jam session during the Poster session/reception - contact Jeff.
 
#*Looking Ahead to Summer 2014 - venues
 
#** Erin Robinson reported on the location search update. We received a proposal from Copper Mountain, CO, a ski resort, that is within our budget. It is about a 90 min shuttle ride to Copper from the Denver Airport. The group discussed the appearance of being at a resort (albeit a ski resort in the summer), but many thought the location was good and given our struggle finding a location the group decided to go ahead and lock Copper down. Erin will move ahead with the contract.
 
#*Business Meeting information
 
#** Karl reported on the proposed revisions to the Foundation bylaws as it relates to the ESIP Federation seats. The Assembly will need to define 6 provisional representatives that may assume seats on the Foundation Board pending the Board's adoption of changes to their bylaws. C&B will meet before the January meeting to try and identify a temporary process for identifying reps.
 
# Committee Reports
 
#* Partnership - John Scialdone reported that there are three new partner applications; Waiting on comments from the Partnership Committee before posting.
 
#* Education - Roberta Johnson reported that the education group wasn't able to have their last call. They are working to improve the ESIP education program. There are new strategies to broaden impact and reach both within ESIP and outside. There is some interest in reviving citizen science
 
#* FiCom - Carol reported that FiCom met and 3 budget proposals were approved and 2 were sent back for more information. 
 
#* IT&I - Cecilia Deluca presented on CoG, a collaborative infrastructure.
 
#* Data Stewardship - Curt Tilmes reported that stewardship the group is working on a brochure for the Data Management training course and there is a draft moving forward. There is also an draft provenance opinion piece. The Data Study group is also very active, including a study scoping workshop at the Winter ESIP Meeting.
 
# Other Business
 
:*Award Committee - We have two applications for the Martha Maiden Award. Annette Schloss will took action to convene the award committee to make a decision on this. Sara Graves will be the past-award participant on the award committee (with the Type Reps and VP).
 
:*Raskin Scholarship Update - A review committee of people who were part of original team that conceived of the fund and award. Part of the group met, but refrained from making a decision until still one member provided input. The winner will be announced at the January meeting and will give a talk at the Summer ESIP Meeting.
 
:*Call for Nominations (still open until Dec. 1)
 
:** Reminder that we have posted the call for nominations for 2014 ESIP Leadership. If you are interested in retaining your seat or would like to nominate someone let Carol or Erin know. Thanks for your leadership this year! A request for candidates to provide a statement - their vision and what they would do if elected. <br>
 
:* Student Fellow Review
 
:** Erin reported that we had 11 applications and requested help with reviewing the applications. Karl Benedict agreed to help with the reviews and Erin would reach out to one more member of the Excom.
 
4. Approval of [[Draft Excom Minutes| October Minutes]]
 
* John Scialdone suggested modification to say "on or about Nov. 1". Stefan Falke motioned to accept the minutes as modified. John Scialdone seconded the motion. The motion passed by acclamation.
 
Meeting adjourned at 12:55
 

Revision as of 19:07, February 15, 2014

Participants: Peter Fox, Sara Graves, Bruce Caron, Tyler Stevens, Ken Keiser, Margaret Mooney, Christine White, Denise Hills, Carol Meyer, Erin Robinson

  1. Introductory Remarks (Peter Fox)
    Peter welcomed the group and thanked everyone for their leadership within ESIP this year. He has already started conversations with Carol, Erin and Emily Law about ESIP work in 2014 particularly as the Federation and Foundation work to develop separate identities moving forward. This separation will have some implications that ExCom will review in the coming year.
  2. Approval of November Minutes
    No one but Carol and Erin were at the Nov. ExCom meeting. The group decided to accept minutes as formality. Sara motioned to accept the minutes and Christine seconded the motion. The minutes were approved by acclimation.
  3. Staff Report (Carol Meyer)
    Carol reported that with the help of the ESIP Visioneers we have a set of suggested themes. The group discussed the themes and settled on: "Linking it Together: Sustainable Software Advancing Science Data and Services". Erin will put out the call for sessions after this meeting. The deadline for the call for sessions is April 13. Erin also mentioned that there are session ideas on the meeting planning page as well as additional details on the venue.
    • GEO
    Carol reported that last year GEO had approached ESIP to upgrade the GEO membership from Observer to Participating Organization. Last month at the GEO plenary in Geneva the new status was approved and ESIP is now a Participating Organization. The expectation that comes with this new status is that ESIP will be an active participant in GEO and GEOSS activities. Currently, a few clusters are considering contributing to the Architecture Implementation Pilot (AIP-7) that is to be announced in the next month.
    Erin reported that she and Carol have pulled together a folder with key resources that may help the ESIP collaboration area leaders. The folder includes a list of all key representatives, links to calendars, ESIP sites and social media, a template 'strategy plan' for 2014 that many groups have already worked on and best practices for webex and running meetings. The group suggested a few other items to add - attendee directory from past meetings, completed collaboration strategy documents
  4. Committee Reports (All)
    • Partnership - Tyler reported that the named a new Type III Rep, Gary Randolph from GLOBE. The committee has received a few new member applications and will meet next month to review them. Finally, Tyler has worked with Carol and Erin on ways to engage current members and ideas for new member welcome packet.
    • Partnership and Finance Committee Members Needed (Gary Randolph, GLOBE has stepped forward for Partnership; Reagan Moore, DICE has stepped forward for Ficom)
    • Constitution & Bylaws - Bruce reported that the group met earlier this month to review past business and the committee is open to changes coming from 3 members. The group plans to look at how to clean-up long-term, inactive membership. The group would also like to move from a floating target % of active members to a numeric quorum. Peter brought up the idea of forming a new nomination committee, so that as the Federation grows and there are contested positions we have a process.
    • Data Stewardship - Denise reported that the group is working on several activities including use cases, the Data Study, Collection Structure and some overlap with the PROV-ES work. The group has two papers that are in final stages of preparation about to go out for review. The Information quality cluster will be spinning up in the next few weeks after recent inactivity.
    • Education - Margaret reported that the group has a new telecon time and hasn't yet met. The group will work with NESTA on a closer partnership this year. Margaret also reported that the ESIP Teacher workshop still has not been funded. She is considering moving this to a virtual event and reaching back to the former teacher workshop participants.
    • IT & I - Carol reported for Matt Austin that the group kicked off the year with Rich Signell giving the Rant/Rave on iPython Notebooks. Erin is working with Matt to identify future speakers for the series.
    • Products & Services - Christine reported that the group is meeting next week. She has reactivated the Testbed configuration board and together they have a 2014 Request for Testbed Proposals. This will be discussed at their first P&S meeting. Finally, the P&S Committee will look at FUNding Friday rules/criteria and update them.
    • Cross-ESIP coordination (Peter Fox) - Peter asked each of the chairs to think about the roles and responsibilities that co-chairs may take in the group this year. He suggested that one role may be to link across ESIP collaboration areas. Sara asked about the role that type reps might play and if there was any analysis on the type of activities. Erin took that as an action and will work with the type reps to answer some of those questions.
    • Replacing Finance & Appropriations Chair
      • Chuck Hutchinson served as both the Finance Committee chair for ESIP and the treasurer of the Foundation. When the Foundation bylaws were updated he could no longer serve on both and resigned his seat on the Foundation Board. Since that time, it's become clear that he's needed on the Foundation Board, so he resigned as FiCom Chair. Chuck worked with Carol and Peter to identify a replacement for ESIP and Bill Teng has stepped forward. There was no discussion from group on Bill. Sara moved to approve Bill as the chair of FiCom. Denise 2nded. Bill was approved by acclimation.
      • There were two other committee seats that needed to be filled after the ESIP Winter Meeting. Christine motioned to accept Gary Randolph for Type III rep to Partnership and Reagan Moore as Type III Rep to Finance. Tyler 2nded. Both were approved by acclimation.
  5. Other Business
    • Sara asked if there are minutes from the ESIP Assembly Meeting. Carol will provide to the group.
    • Strategic Plan - Peter reported that ESIP is currently due to update its strategic plan. Emily Law will lead this effort.
    • WDS Expression of Interest - The group took an action for Erin to review the implications of WDS membership and report back to the group next month. Those familiar with WDS will support Erin.
    • Finding a New Time to Meet - Doodle Poll - The current meeting time isn't available for Vice President Emily Law. Carol requested that the group respond to the doodle poll, so that we can find a new time.

The meeting adjourned at 2:09.