Difference between revisions of "Draft Excom Minutes"

Revision as of 07:28, June 28, 2012

ESIP Federation Executive Committee, June 14, 2012

Participants: Matt Austin, Karl Benedict, Steve Berrick, Stefan Falke, Patricia Huff, Chuck Hutchinson, Ken Keiser, Chris Lenhardt, Carol Meyer, Curt Tilmes

1. Approval of April minutes
Ken Keiser made a motion to adopt the minutes as drafted. The motion was seconded by Steve Berrick. Without discussion, the minutes were approved by acclamation.

2. National Climate Assessment Network (Curt Tilmes, NASA/USGCRP)
Curt Tilmes provided an overview of the USGCRP’s efforts to build a global change knowledge base. The USGCRP mission is to understand integrated science, perform education and communication around global change, to conduct sustained assessments, and inform decision support.
The 2012 Climate Assessment has several new features, including broader partnerships that help build a long-term capacity for doing future assessments. The NCANet (National Climate Assessment Network) is a non-federal body that coordinates external contributions into the National Climate Assessment.

ESIP could help be a communication conduit to/from the NCA team.
ESIP could help make connections to partner organizations.
ESIP Air Quality Working Group Chair (Glynis Lough) is the new Chief of Staff at USGCRP.
ESIP stewardship, drupal, semantic web activities are of particular interest to Curt’s work at the USGCRP.
Participation in NCANet is largely ad hoc.

The Executive Committee was asked to consider membership in NCANet. The Excom wondered if it made more sense for NCANet to join ESIP. There was no consensus as to moving forward but at minimum, it was understood that ESIP could assist in communicating with its members about relevant opportunities and items of importance.

3. Excom Business

Carol Meyer reported that the Excom approved via email vote the creation of an ESIP Commons Working Group and the Energy and Climate Working Group (formerly Cluster). Both will report up to the Excom.
During last year’s consideration of nominations for the Martha Maiden Award, the Type Rep reviewers indicated that additional review criteria necessary. The Excom was asked to appoint a team to look at review criteria (e.g. consensus v. unanimity approach, number of reviewers, other review criteria). Vice President Annette Schloss agreed to chair this team which will include the ESIP Type Reps. The team will report back to the Excom.
Carol Meyer reported that attendance at the summer meeting had grown to 154 at present (10 virtual). The agenda is in place for the meeting and all looks to be very positive in a tough travel climate.
Several of the Committees are pulling together their state of the art documents for different activities. Both the Products and Services and Data Stewardship Committees are leading efforts. The final documents will have a permanent home in the ESIP Commons.

4. Committee Reports
The Constitution and Bylaws Committee will meet on June 18 to pick up where they left off in January.

5. Other Business
There was no other business.
Chris Lenhardt made a motion to adjourn the meeting with a second by Steve Berrick. The meeting adjourned at 3:05.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-'''ESIP Federation Executive Committee, May 10, 2012'''
+'''ESIP Federation Executive Committee, June 14, 2012'''
-Attendees: John Scialdone,  Ken Keiser, Stefan Falke, Annette Schloss, Karl Benedict, Shailendra Kumar, Carol Meyer, Erin Robinson<br>
+Participants: Matt Austin, Karl Benedict, Steve Berrick, Stefan Falke, Patricia Huff, Chuck Hutchinson, Ken Keiser, Chris Lenhardt, Carol Meyer, Curt Tilmes
-# Approval of [[Draft Excom Minutes| April minutes]] - minutes could not be approved because a quorum could not be established.
+. Approval of April minutes<br>
-# Summer Meeting Update -
+Ken Keiser made a motion to adopt the minutes as drafted. The motion was seconded by Steve Berrick. Without discussion, the minutes were approved by acclamation.<br>
-#* Over 50 people are registered.
-#* Including 4-5 virtual participants.
-#* A reminder was given to make hotel reservations and go ahead and register for the meeting to help us establish a head count.
-#* A draft schedule was posted several weeks ago and a note to add space for C&B on the agenda was made.
-# ESIP Commons Governance Working Group [[ESIP Commons Governance Working Group| proposal]] ([http://commons.esipfed.org/ commons.esipfed.org])
-#* Need a light touch governance model to oversee the content being added to the governance group.
-:*Two types of members - editorial workgroup and board for high level oversight.
-#* Group also discussed distinction between wiki - dynamic content generation and commons - outcomes (may still be living documents).
-#* If there is interest from others in the group please let Erin know.
-#* Recommendation from Excom group was to form a Working Group.
-#* An electronic vote will be facilitated with the full Executive Committee before the June telecon
-# Energy & Climate Cluster Working Group proposal ([http://wiki.esipfed.org/index.php/Energy_and_Climate Draft White Paper]) -  Shailendra Kumar
-#* Energy Cluster had first session at January 2010 meeting and became a cluster in July 2010.
-#* The group has been working on a dynamic decision tool catalog. The group has been collaboratively writing a white paper that will be used to solicit funding. There has been significant cross-agency interest and input into the white paper. The group is leveraging ESIP collaboration group expertise such as drupal and semantic web.
-#* The cluster made the formal request to become a Work Group, in part to allow it to request seed funding for the decision support tool's development
-#* The members on the were supportive of this request.
-#* An electronic vote will be facilitated with the full Executive Committee before the June telecon
-# Other Business
-#*Committee Reports
-#** C&B - Chris is meeting with Carol to discuss how to move forward w/C&B
-#** P&S - Ken will push to get state of art docs from each of the testbed projects.
-'''ESIP Federation Executive Committee, April 12, 2012'''
+. National Climate Assessment Network (Curt Tilmes, NASA/USGCRP)<br>
+Curt Tilmes provided an overview of the USGCRP’s efforts to build a global change knowledge base. The USGCRP mission is to understand integrated science, perform education and communication around global change, to conduct
+sustained assessments, and inform decision support.<br>
+The 2012 Climate Assessment has several new features, including broader partnerships that help build a long-term capacity for doing future assessments. The NCANet (National Climate Assessment Network) is a non-federal body that coordinates external contributions into the National Climate Assessment.<br>
+:*ESIP could help be a communication conduit to/from the NCA team.
+:*ESIP could help make connections to partner organizations.
+:*ESIP Air Quality Working Group Chair (Glynis Lough) is the new Chief of Staff at USGCRP.
+:*ESIP stewardship, drupal, semantic web activities are of particular interest to Curt’s work at the USGCRP.
+:*Participation in NCANet is largely ''ad hoc''.
+The Executive Committee was asked to consider membership in NCANet. The Excom wondered if it made more sense for NCANet to join ESIP. There was no consensus as to moving forward but at minimum, it was understood that ESIP could assist in communicating with its members about relevant opportunities and items of importance. <br>
-Attendees: Curt TIlmes, John Scialdone, Stephen Berrick,  Ken Keiser, Stefan Falke, Annette Schloss, Becky Reid, Patricia Huff, Brian Wilson, Sayeed Choudhury Carol Meyer, Erin Robinson<br>
+. Excom Business<br>
+:*Carol Meyer reported that the Excom approved via email vote the creation of an ESIP Commons Working Group and the Energy and Climate Working Group (formerly Cluster). Both will report up to the Excom.
+:*During last year’s consideration of nominations for the Martha Maiden Award, the Type Rep reviewers indicated that additional review criteria necessary. The Excom was asked to appoint a team to look at review criteria (e.g. consensus v. unanimity approach, number of reviewers, other review criteria). Vice President Annette Schloss agreed to chair this team which will include the ESIP Type Reps. The team will report back to the Excom.
+:*Carol Meyer reported that attendance at the summer meeting had grown to 154 at present (10 virtual). The agenda is in place for the meeting and all looks to be very positive in a tough travel climate.
+:*Several of the Committees are pulling together their state of the art documents for different activities. Both the Products and Services and Data Stewardship Committees are leading efforts. The final documents will have a permanent home in the ESIP Commons.
-The meeting was called to order by Vice President Annette Schloss at 2:08 pm EDT.<br>
+. Committee Reports <br>
+The Constitution and Bylaws Committee will meet on June 18 to pick up where they left off in January.<br>
-# Approval of [[ExCom March 2012| March minutes]] - A motion to adopt was made by Steve Berrick, with John Scialdone offering a second. The minutes were approved by acclamation.
-# Summer Meeting Update - Carol updated ExCom that 28 sessions have been submitted for breakouts and workshops at the summer meeting. Registration is off to a slow start, but that is consistent with patterns we have seen in previous years.
-#* The plenary sessions are coming together:
-#** The first 1.5 hour speakers are awaiting confirmation, but will be two solo presenters and then a panel highlighting NASA and NOAA innovation
-#** The second 1.5 hour will highlight the "Innovators among us" - ESIP members will present in 5 or 9 minute presentations about their work or ESIP collaboration area work. [https://docs.google.com/a/esipfed.org/spreadsheet/viewform?formkey=dGJNeWVFc2lKVmFhb0gtNktXZTcwaXc6MQ#gid=0 Submit your ideas by May 15] for a talk.
-#** Lea Shanley, Director of the Commons Lab at Woodrow Wilson Center, will provide a lunchtime talk on the connection between technology and policy.
-# C&B Chair Vacancy - A call went out to the current members of Constitution and Bylaws Committee (C&B) to see if there was interest in stepping in as chair. No one on the committee is able at this time to step in as chair. Chris Lenhardt, former ESIP President, is interested in the position. He worked with Rob closely on the latest round of changes and is familiar with the work that is left to do. Both C&B and ExCom felt Chris was a good replacement. ExCom voted and by acclamation Chris Lenhardt was accepted as Chair.
-# Raskin Memorial – Rob Raskin's sister approached the Federation on behalf of Rob's family, to start a memorial for Rob within ESIP. A small working group of Rob’s colleagues and collaborators was put together to begin discussions on an appropriate memorial. The working group is open and if interested, let Carol know. The ideas being discussed are posted on a wiki page for the [[Raskin Scholarship]].
-# Other Business <br>
-#*Student Fellow Update - Erin reported that there were 40 applications submitted and the Foundation hopes to grow the fellowship to 10 Fellows. The applications are going through the review process now and by ExCom next month  a new class of fellows should be in place.
-#* Foundation/ESIP Funding Update - The Foundation submitted proposals to both NASA and NOAA on behalf of the Federation in the last two weeks.
-#* Committee Reports <br>
-#** P&S - Ken reported that the State of Art template will be filled out by all of the testbed projects. P&S is also establishing IT infrastructure to support the projects via the cloud and GitHub as a source code repository. Christine White will have the Discovery testbed deployed on the Amazon Cloud by the next P&S meeting.
-#** Education - Becky Reid reported that Education would also work to fill out a state of art template. Margaret Mooney represented the ESIP Education Committee at NESTA and had a lot of interest in the Teacher Workshop.
-#** Stewardship - Curt reported that the Committee would also work on a state of art template. Also in collaboration with Peter Fox, he is working on the Global Climate Information System and looking to tie that back to the ESIP Stewardship Committee.
-#** IT&I - Erin reported that the IT&I Committee has laid out the next several months of Rants and Raves - CF Rant, Ted Habermann, May; Cloud Computing, Rick Martin, June; US GIN/ISO 19115 Updates, Steve Richard, September; Others welcome.
-A motion to adjourn was made by Ken Keiser and seconded by Steve Berrick.
+. Other Business<br>
-The meeting adjourned at 2:46 EDT.
+There was no other business. <br>
-<br>
+Chris Lenhardt made a motion to adjourn the meeting with a second by Steve Berrick. The meeting adjourned at 3:05.