110915 DataManagementNotes

From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

Participants: Ruth Duerr, Ron Weaver, Bob Downs, Matt Mayernik, Jeff Arnfield, Erin Robinson, Carol Meyer

  • Review action items
    • Ruth - breadcrumbs on the module. Name on each slide in upper left corner is sufficient. (closed)
    • Erin - Created email for questions related to short course (closed)
    • Ruth - Drafted author guidelines. (closed)
  • Workshop update?
    • AGU status?
  • Modules status
  • Review author's guide
    • Ruth created the author's guide
      • 10 slides - does it include shell or content? ~ 7 body pages per module
      • don't want module titles and what's on the wiki to to diverge
      • In general reference - add style guide for references - AGU/AMS style guide
  • Discuss module review process
    • Review Criteria:
      • Add to author's guide what review process
      • Want to make sure the content is balanced, concise and complete
      • Conforms to author's guide
      • Reasonable ref check
      • Understandability/Simplicity - to non-expert (right level of details)
        • Undergraduate level or general college level
        • reasonably simple for non expert to understand
    • Review Process:
      • review board
      • Blind peer-review
      • Blind review within the board
      • Bob Downs volunteered to help review.
      • Each module reviewed by one other person and need a way to track that.
      • Reviewers can make changes; evolve as we go w/ questions.
      • When modules are nearly set - running them by NOAA for review.
        • NESDIS Headquarters -EDMC (Jeff DLB/Lewis)
  • Schedule - October 15 for draft
  • Stipend/Honorarium - $100 If we think we need someone to edit/vet these may be good to pay.
    • Could UIUC students review?
  • Actions
    • Ruth add contact email and version to template and upload to the wiki
    • Erin email group when clarify identifier issue.
    • Carol - Action for Glossary.
    • Ruth will follow-up on involving UIUC Students
    • Carol will follow-up on NOAA NESDIS reviewers
    • Bob Downs volunteered to review
    • Ruth will add review criteria to author guidelines
    • Matt Mayernik is looking into options for reference style guidelines and report back with a few options
    • Carol will report back when AGU side meeting is confirmed.