Difference between revisions of "Sustainable Data Management/20160721 ESIP summer mtg"

From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
Line 19: Line 19:
 
# migration
 
# migration
  
Value of repo depends on a combination of their activities, and maturity.
+
Value of repo depends on a combination of their activities, and maturity. e.g.,.
 +
* value should go up with higher levels, but how to quantify is difficult
 +
* NASA L1-L4 levels.
  
Users: a similar degree of differences between their expectations/needs
+
Users: a similar degree of differences between their expectations/needs, and the value they might assign (or could be assigned to them)
  
 
Comments:
 
Comments:
 
# when companies do ROI, it is based on cost-to-produce, and they anticipate an amount in return. Ours: it costs $x to produce, and we give it all away. so no value is really known.
 
# when companies do ROI, it is based on cost-to-produce, and they anticipate an amount in return. Ours: it costs $x to produce, and we give it all away. so no value is really known.
 
# Universities when economic impact for their existence: what methodology do they use?  
 
# Universities when economic impact for their existence: what methodology do they use?  
# studies on NSDES - valuation of satellite data (economist with UCAR)
+
# studies on NSDES - valuation of satellite data (economist with UCAR) - perhaps NASA has some of these also.
 +
#

Revision as of 15:22, July 21, 2016

  • Speakers:
  • * Bob Downs - intro/Beagrie 2016 - see "Resources" for Beagrie rpt
  • * Anne Wilson - JISC report - see "Resources"
  • * Ruth Duerr - Lead in to next steps

Definitions/context: http://cirss.lis.illinois.edu/Documents/Publications_docs/Choudhury_2013a.pdf

  • Levels:
  1. storage
  2. archiving
  3. preservation
  4. curation
  • Maturity:

{ref here}

  1. data services
  2. data checking
  3. metadata quality
  4. migration

Value of repo depends on a combination of their activities, and maturity. e.g.,.

  • value should go up with higher levels, but how to quantify is difficult
  • NASA L1-L4 levels.

Users: a similar degree of differences between their expectations/needs, and the value they might assign (or could be assigned to them)

Comments:

  1. when companies do ROI, it is based on cost-to-produce, and they anticipate an amount in return. Ours: it costs $x to produce, and we give it all away. so no value is really known.
  2. Universities when economic impact for their existence: what methodology do they use?
  3. studies on NSDES - valuation of satellite data (economist with UCAR) - perhaps NASA has some of these also.