Telecon (2019-07-03)

From Federation of Earth Science Information Partners
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Analyzing keyword usage in the IMCR)
(Revisiting controlled vocabularies)
Line 18: Line 18:
  
 
====Revisiting controlled vocabularies====
 
====Revisiting controlled vocabularies====
'''Science domain'''
+
'''Science domain CV'''
 
* If broadly applicable, then better to include all domains rather than none.
 
* If broadly applicable, then better to include all domains rather than none.
 
* [http://vocab.lternet.edu/vocab/vocab/index.php Consider the LTER Controlled vocabulary "disciplines" category of terms]
 
* [http://vocab.lternet.edu/vocab/vocab/index.php Consider the LTER Controlled vocabulary "disciplines" category of terms]
Line 24: Line 24:
 
* planning
 
* planning
 
** project management - Too broad. Remove
 
** project management - Too broad. Remove
** process management (e.g. Kelper) - Rename as "workflow management"
+
** process management (e.g. Kelper) - Rename as "workflow management". Move to integration.
 
* collection
 
* collection
** egress - Rename as "export", perhaps delete
+
** egress - Rename as "export" or delete.
 
** ingress - Rename as "import"
 
** ingress - Rename as "import"
** streaming data - to data streaming
+
** streaming data - to "data streaming" or "streaming"
** storage > data base design to planning
+
** storage - Rename as "storing"
 +
** data base design - Potentially new term to under planning
 
* assurance
 
* assurance
** cleaning falls under assurance or control
+
** spatial data editing - Remove term
** spatial data editing/spatial transformation - remove "spatial"
+
** spatial transformation - Remove term (already exists under integration where it belongs)
 
* describing
 
* describing
** mind mapping to planning
+
** mind mapping - Move to planning
** metadata rendering to preservation or to transformation
+
** metadata rendering - Remove term since it falls under transformation
** semantic* sub-terms under semantic operations or annotation
+
** semantic* - Combine into new term "annotation"
 
* preservation
 
* preservation
** notification is esoteric (communication)
+
** Notification is esoteric - Remove
** transformation/formatting  
+
** transformation/formatting may belong under this hierarchy
 
* discovery
 
* discovery
** retrieval and mining under collection
+
** retrieval and mining - Move under collection
** crawling - might be too specific
+
** crawling - Remove (too specific)
 
* integration
 
* integration
 
** aggregation - add term
 
** aggregation - add term

Revision as of 14:31, 3 July 2019

Return to Archive

Contents

Attendees

  • John Porter
  • Colin Smith
  • Stevan Earl

Agenda

  • Analyzing keyword usage in the IMCR Extracting metadata from Ontosoft, parsing, and analytical approaches.
  • Revisiting controlled vocabularies Review IMCR terms, identify and integrate science domain into IMCR best practices.
  • ESIP summer meeting plans Review summer meeting presentation and participant activities.

Discussion

Analyzing keyword usage in the IMCR

Some cursory ideas for analyzing the IMCR contents, primarily for purposes of the summer ESIP meeting in a few weeks.

  • Perhaps a cluster analysis of keywords
  • Word cloud of term use
  • Histogram of term use

Revisiting controlled vocabularies

Science domain CV

IMCR CV

  • planning
    • project management - Too broad. Remove
    • process management (e.g. Kelper) - Rename as "workflow management". Move to integration.
  • collection
    • egress - Rename as "export" or delete.
    • ingress - Rename as "import"
    • streaming data - to "data streaming" or "streaming"
    • storage - Rename as "storing"
    • data base design - Potentially new term to under planning
  • assurance
    • spatial data editing - Remove term
    • spatial transformation - Remove term (already exists under integration where it belongs)
  • describing
    • mind mapping - Move to planning
    • metadata rendering - Remove term since it falls under transformation
    • semantic* - Combine into new term "annotation"
  • preservation
    • Notification is esoteric - Remove
    • transformation/formatting may belong under this hierarchy
  • discovery
    • retrieval and mining - Move under collection
    • crawling - Remove (too specific)
  • integration
    • aggregation - add term
    • merging - added term
    • interoperatbility - move to preservation
    • conversion and reformatting are very simmilar - reformatting under conversion

ESIP summer meeting plans

We never got around to discussing this.

Action items

Revise the IMCR CV considering the notes above and feedback from the RFC. (Colin)

Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox