SW OPortal Discussion

From Federation of Earth Science Information Partners
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Justifying Semantic Web Repository Business Costs: aded references)
(Ontology Portal Evaluation Approach: reformatted headers)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
= Ontology Portal Evaluation Approach =
+
= Ontology Portal Evaluation Approach: Introduction =
  
 
This page supports ESIP's evaluation of semantic repository solutions. It considers both comparative evaluations of different technology approaches, and a business cost justification model that could be used to justify funding semantic web repositories. All ESIP members (and anyone else with an account on this wiki) are welcome to contribute.
 
This page supports ESIP's evaluation of semantic repository solutions. It considers both comparative evaluations of different technology approaches, and a business cost justification model that could be used to justify funding semantic web repositories. All ESIP members (and anyone else with an account on this wiki) are welcome to contribute.
  
== Comparing Semantic Repository Implementations ==
+
= Comparing Semantic Repository Implementations =
  
 
In general in this document:
 
In general in this document:
Line 9: Line 9:
 
* URI is used to mean a unique web identifier, aka IRI; it usually but not always is a URL.
 
* URI is used to mean a unique web identifier, aka IRI; it usually but not always is a URL.
  
=== Features/Services ===
+
== Features/Services ==
  
 
These are the functions offered by the repository.  
 
These are the functions offered by the repository.  
  
==== Ingest capabilities ====
+
=== Ingest capabilities ===
  
==== Search capabilities ====
+
=== Search capabilities ===
  
 
How detailed are the search options in the UI? Are faceted searches available?  
 
How detailed are the search options in the UI? Are faceted searches available?  
  
==== Browse capabilities ====
+
=== Browse capabilities ===
  
==== Display capabilities ====
+
=== Display capabilities ===
  
==== Download capabilities ====
+
What options are available for displaying and viewing concepts, ontologies, and metadata?
  
==== Mapping capabilities ====
+
=== Download capabilities ===
  
==== Inferencing capabilities ====
+
=== Mapping capabilities ===
  
==== Query capabilities ====
+
=== Inferencing capabilities ===
  
 +
=== Query capabilities ===
  
=== Protocols ===
+
== Protocols ==
  
 
Protocols describe how the repository makes its information, submissions, and entries available: what syntax, semantics, and specifications are supported in the data and commands that go into the system, and come out of it?
 
Protocols describe how the repository makes its information, submissions, and entries available: what syntax, semantics, and specifications are supported in the data and commands that go into the system, and come out of it?
  
==== Ontology download formats ====
+
=== Ontology download formats ===
  
==== Ontology upload formats ====
+
=== Ontology upload formats ===
  
==== URI format for concepts and artifacts
+
=== URI format for concepts and artifacts
  
==== API support ====
+
=== API support ===
  
 
How many/which features are available to other applications via API calls? Are these calls REST-based?
 
How many/which features are available to other applications via API calls? Are these calls REST-based?
Line 48: Line 49:
 
How is the URI for each concept in the repository represented? How is the URI for each artifact represented? Are the offered URIs versioned, unversioned, or both?
 
How is the URI for each concept in the repository represented? How is the URI for each artifact represented? Are the offered URIs versioned, unversioned, or both?
  
=== Usability ===
+
== Usability ==
  
==== Ease of content submission ====
+
=== Ease of content submission ===
  
==== Ease of content updates ====
+
=== Ease of content updates ===
  
==== Documentation ====
+
=== Documentation ===
  
==== Responsiveness ====
+
=== Responsiveness ===
  
==== Reliability/Uptime ====
+
=== Reliability/Uptime ===
  
=== Authentication and Security ===
+
== Authentication and Security ==
  
 
What types of login features are supported?
 
What types of login features are supported?
  
=== Support for Teams and Roles ===
+
== Support for Teams and Roles ==
  
 
Can teams be defined of multiple members? Can multiple members of a team edit the same ontology?
 
Can teams be defined of multiple members? Can multiple members of a team edit the same ontology?
  
=== Cost ===
+
== Cost ==
  
 
Costs are given in labor hours and funds required to start and operate the service.
 
Costs are given in labor hours and funds required to start and operate the service.
  
==== Installation ====
+
=== Installation ===
  
==== Operations ====
+
=== Operations ===
  
==== Maintenance ====
+
=== Maintenance ===
  
== Justifying Semantic Web Repository Business Costs ==
+
= Justifying Semantic Web Repository Business Costs =
  
 
(see the [SW OPortal Discussion:Talk|Discussion] page for ideas.)
 
(see the [SW OPortal Discussion:Talk|Discussion] page for ideas.)
  
== References ==
+
= References =
  
 
[1] ODM2 evaluation of MMI ORR: https://github.com/ODM2/ODM2/blob/07e4e30fc4d6763b8bcae771ffbb7228fc5a3f65/doc/ODM2Docs/concept_controlledvocabs.md
 
[1] ODM2 evaluation of MMI ORR: https://github.com/ODM2/ODM2/blob/07e4e30fc4d6763b8bcae771ffbb7228fc5a3f65/doc/ODM2Docs/concept_controlledvocabs.md

Latest revision as of 23:32, 24 March 2016

Contents

[edit] Ontology Portal Evaluation Approach: Introduction

This page supports ESIP's evaluation of semantic repository solutions. It considers both comparative evaluations of different technology approaches, and a business cost justification model that could be used to justify funding semantic web repositories. All ESIP members (and anyone else with an account on this wiki) are welcome to contribute.

[edit] Comparing Semantic Repository Implementations

In general in this document:

  • 'ontology' refers to any semantic artifact, whether expressed in OWL/RDF, another OWL representation, or a simpler form like Excel or CSV that can be converted into a semantic artifact.
  • URI is used to mean a unique web identifier, aka IRI; it usually but not always is a URL.

[edit] Features/Services

These are the functions offered by the repository.

[edit] Ingest capabilities

[edit] Search capabilities

How detailed are the search options in the UI? Are faceted searches available?

[edit] Browse capabilities

[edit] Display capabilities

What options are available for displaying and viewing concepts, ontologies, and metadata?

[edit] Download capabilities

[edit] Mapping capabilities

[edit] Inferencing capabilities

[edit] Query capabilities

[edit] Protocols

Protocols describe how the repository makes its information, submissions, and entries available: what syntax, semantics, and specifications are supported in the data and commands that go into the system, and come out of it?

[edit] Ontology download formats

[edit] Ontology upload formats

=== URI format for concepts and artifacts

[edit] API support

How many/which features are available to other applications via API calls? Are these calls REST-based?

How is the URI for each concept in the repository represented? How is the URI for each artifact represented? Are the offered URIs versioned, unversioned, or both?

[edit] Usability

[edit] Ease of content submission

[edit] Ease of content updates

[edit] Documentation

[edit] Responsiveness

[edit] Reliability/Uptime

[edit] Authentication and Security

What types of login features are supported?

[edit] Support for Teams and Roles

Can teams be defined of multiple members? Can multiple members of a team edit the same ontology?

[edit] Cost

Costs are given in labor hours and funds required to start and operate the service.

[edit] Installation

[edit] Operations

[edit] Maintenance

[edit] Justifying Semantic Web Repository Business Costs

(see the [SW OPortal Discussion:Talk|Discussion] page for ideas.)

[edit] References

[1] ODM2 evaluation of MMI ORR: https://github.com/ODM2/ODM2/blob/07e4e30fc4d6763b8bcae771ffbb7228fc5a3f65/doc/ODM2Docs/concept_controlledvocabs.md

Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox