Difference between revisions of "Draft Excom Minutes"

From Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP)
m
Line 1: Line 1:
 
'''Attendees'''
 
'''Attendees'''
 
<br />
 
<br />
Emily Law, President<br />
+
Emily Law, President<br />  
Christine White, Vice President<br />
 
 
Danie Kinkade, Chair, Partnership<br />
 
Danie Kinkade, Chair, Partnership<br />
Ken Keiser, Chair, C&B<br />
+
Ken Keiser, Chair, C&B<br />  
Bob Arko, Type I Rep<br />
+
Bob Arko, Type I Rep<br />  
 
Ted Habermann, Type III Rep<br />
 
Ted Habermann, Type III Rep<br />
LuAnn Dahlman, Chair, Education<br />
+
LuAnn Dahlman, Chair, Education<br />
Ethan Davis, Chair, IT & I<br />
+
Ethan Davis, Chair, IT & I<br />  
Denise Hills, Chair, Nominations<br />
+
Justin Goldstein, Chair, Data Stewardship<br />
Tom Narock, Chair, Semantic Technologies<br />
+
Soren Scott, Chair, P & S<br />  
 
Erin Robinson, Staff<br />
 
Erin Robinson, Staff<br />
Annie Burgess, Staff<br />
+
Annie Burgess, Staff<br />  
Rebecca Fowler, Staff
+
Rebecca Fowler, Staff  
  
 
'''Mintes'''
 
'''Mintes'''
# Approval of  [[Approved_Excom_Minutes/Excom_2016|Feb & March Minutes]]
+
# Approval of  [[Approved_Excom_Minutes/Excom_2016|April Minutes]]
#* Denise Hills motioned to approve the February Minutes and LuAnn Dahlman seconded. The Minutes were approved by acclamation.
+
#* Bill Teng motioned to approve the April Minutes and LuAnn Dahlman seconded. The Minutes were approved by acclamation.
#* Denise Hills motioned to approve the March Minutes and Ken Keiser seconded.  The Minutes were approved by acclamation.
 
 
# President's Report
 
# President's Report
#*Highlights
+
#*Highlight
#**Sponsors visit: Erin, Christine and I met with NASA and NOAA sponsors. The purpose was to provide our sponsors an update of ESIP activities that are of specific interest to their programs and to hear how ESIP can serve them better. Other topics included ESIP Evaluation, International Data Week, Earth Science User Conference, etc.  
+
#**The Foundation for Earth Science: FES board meeting was held on April 29, 2016. It covered ESIP report (sponsors visit, summer meeting, endorsement of “Open Data in Big Data World”, ESIP evaluation), Foundation/ESIP organization structure update, finance report and ESIP Director report (proposals, letter of collaboration, staff update and training, near term activities).  
#**Potential partners visit: We also visited US-GEO/OSTP, NIH and World Bank. The purpose was to provide potential partner/collaborative organizations a high-level overview of ESIP, share with them our strategic vision and activities, learn about their synergetic activites, and explore opportunities and collaboration.
+
#**Open, Public, Electronic and Necessary (OPEN) Government Data Act: The Center for Data Innovation (CDI) was seeking co-signers in their letter of support for this legislation to be introduced into the U.S. House and Senate. Upon reviewing the proposed legislation and summary, the FES board members unanimously voted in favor to support this bill. The proposal, summary and support letter can be found at: https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/0B_2czh6FTo34OE1HTWE1OXlodk0. CDI published a [https://www.datainnovation.org/2016/05/center-for-data-innovation-and-47-other-organizations-urge-congressional-action-on-bipartisan-open-government-data-act/ press release] regarding the letter of support.
#**Takeaways and actions from these visits can be found at: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PBJFzHSGInlQYSKAlLzYXY04nXqLcMTBGvyA_gd4HJQ/edit
+
#*FYI
#**Significance: Congratulations to H.K. "Rama" Ramapriyan for having been elected as the Vice Chair of Data Stewardship Committee.  Congratulations to Rich Signell for having been appointed as the Vice Chair of IT&T Committee.
+
#**JPL new leadership: Michael M. Watkins, the Clare Cockrell Williams Centennial Chair in Aerospace Engineering and Director of the Center for Space Research at The University of Texas at Austin, and a former leader at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, has been appointed to serve as Director of JPL and Vice President at Caltech effective July 1, 2016.  
#**Significance: Thanks to all the Committees, Work Groups and Clusters that have finalized their Annual Work Plans.
 
 
# Staff Report  
 
# Staff Report  
#* Highlights
+
#* Highlights  
#** Meeting News - Summer Meeting Location update; Winter Meeting Save the date - Jan 11-13, 2017, Bethesda, MD
+
#** Erin - Evaluation is going well. Interviews are in progress and survey questions need review. Survey will go out next week. Last quarter was a heavy fundraising/proposal writing quarter. We submitted two proposals for basic ESIP support + Testbed work, co-I on three NSF proposals that would utilize ESIP framework and wrote 9 letters of support. Confirmed two of three plenary speakers - Ben Preston, ORNL, Ellen Prager, Earth2Ocean and Jon Marino (To Be Confirmed).
#*** The HB2 legislation in North Carolina has created a need to change venues for the ESIP Summer Meeting. The meeting will move from the UNC Friday Center to the Durham Convention Center. The Durham Convention Center is a private facility that provides unisex single-stall bathrooms. The co-located DataONE meeting is in agreement that moving locations is appropriate. ESIP is not able to move the meeting outside of North Carolina as travel arrangements have already been made into the Raleigh-Durham airport.  
+
#** Annie B. - Working on membership database; Next round of evaluation testbed will kick-off in July; Summer Meeting draft schedule is posted.
#** Proposal Updates: NOAA Proposal Submitted! USGS Request for Proposal
+
#** Rebecca - Developing a Communication Strategy; AGU Data Blog (looking for contributing authors); Led development of [http://www.esipfed.org/node/9170 2015 Annual Report] - feedback welcome.  
#** Annie Keyes will be on medical leave for two weeks, starting April 22nd.  
+
#** Dan - Migrated ESIP to GoToMeeting; Working on the ImHere Check-in System. This is ready for use on ESIP telecons to begin familiarizing with tool.
#** ESIP staff will circulate the draft Summer Meeting schedule for comment next week.
+
#** Annie K. - Recovering well! Back to work on Summer Meeting logistics.
 +
#* Actions: 
 +
#** [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_tcNiSd3Gy0hahYF3tIXp_MiiSN5M8Fi7zcM0ET84Ek/edit Review Survey Q's] and add others interested in knowing about.  
 +
#** Review [https://2016esipsummermeeting.sched.org/?iframe=no Summer Meeting Schedule]; Send comments to Annie B.
 +
#** Make Summer travel plans. Contact Annie K.
 +
#** Contribute to the [https://blogs.agu.org/geospace/category/data/ AGU Data Blog] - contact Rebecca
 +
#** Use the ImHere App on your next Telecon!
 
# Committee Reports  
 
# Committee Reports  
 
#* C&B  
 
#* C&B  
#** Staying tuned into Fed-Foundation integration discussions with respect to C&B interests
+
#::*Discussions with Ficom (Bill), P&S (Soren), and others about the location and management of [[List_of_Polices_and_Procedures|policies and procedures (P&P) documents]] on the wiki
#** Discussed Policy & Procedure (P&P) documents and logistics - see [[List_of_Polices_and_Procedures|draft hosting page]]
 
#** Drafted [[2016C%26BPlans|C&B Plans page]] for inclusion with requested Group Plans
 
 
#* Finance
 
#* Finance
#** No budget activity this month.
+
#::*Starting to draft process documents, based on our discussion notes over the past year, to be included in C&B's policies and procedures (P&P) wiki page.
#** Some discussions with C&B on ESIP P&P page.  
+
#::*Will hold an informal Ficom meeting at ESIP Summer.
 +
#::*Either together with this meeting or separately, will make Ficom available to any group planning to submit a budget for FY17.
 +
#::*For discussion: Excom (I think) has discussed the possibility of scheduling an informal session at ESIP Summer for those groups that got funding for FY16 to give a short report.
 
#* Partnership
 
#* Partnership
#** Reviewed new member applications, requested additional information where necessary; ready to recommend to Assembly.
+
#** Reviewed, vetted and posted five new membership applications: Geospatialmetadata.com, Cyber Infrastructure Research and Development Lab for Earth Sciences (CIRDLES), Open Geospatial Consortium, Ronin Institutue, and EarthCube.  Posting of last application went up on 22 April, will be viewed for 30days for comment, then move on to voting by Assembly. Next meeting will focus on review and update of new member packet in time for new member distribution; to include addition of welcome letter from Emily, and completion of 'code of conduct' drafted by previous committee.
#** Drafted Committee strategic plan.
 
#** Recieved ESIP Welcome letter for New Member Packet; review/edits continue.
 
 
#* Data Stewardship
 
#* Data Stewardship
#** Election of H.K. Ramapriyan ("Rama") as co-chair
+
#::*During the April monthly meeting, Data Stewardship Committee member, Ge Peng, provided a progress report regarding the work on Data Stewardship Maturity Matrix (DSMM). The key highlights included the current structure of the DSMM as well as the pilot program that was being conducted at the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) in order to demonstrate the utility and establish baselines for DSMM in the NCEI environment/context. Peng also shared that there would be two DSMM related sessions at the ESIP 2016 Summer Meeting. In addtion to Peng's updates on the DSMM, the Data Stewardship Committee also had a guest speaker, Jon Jablonski, from the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB). Jon is the Head of Map & Image Laboratory at UCSB, and his presentation discussed the types of geographic information system and spatial data services that are being provided at UCSB. Finally, before concluding the meeting, Committee member, Ruth Duerr, shared with the meeting attendees regarding the Data Citation and Attribution in Linguistics (https://sites.google.com/a/hawaii.edu/data-citation/workshop2) Workshop she attended. Ruth felt the group might have the potential to be the Coalition for Publishing Data in the Earth and Space Sciences (COPDESS) for the linguistic discipline.  
#** March Telecon included a report out from RDA attendees and presentation + QA - Jennifer Saleem­ Arrigo on NOAA's Implementation of PARR. For more details on any of the above: [[Interagency_Data_Stewardship/LifeCycle/Preservation_Forum/TeleconNotes/2016-03-21meetingnotes|Meeting Notes]]
 
#** The Data Stewardship brought forward the request that ESIP endorses the international accord "Open Data in a Big Data World."
 
#***'''MOTION''' by Rama:  I move that the ESIP Federation endorse  the international accord “Open Data in a Big Data World”. The endorsement form and details can be found at https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1LGAoUnS3vJ1-3yc5d-PZNlMyGoeKRNm4fbwXnL1qw78/viewform.
 
#*** Denise Hills made a motion to endorse the Open Data in a Big Data World accord. LuAnn seconds.
 
#*** Motion approved.
 
 
#* Education
 
#* Education
#** Education completed our Strategic Planning discussion and will post results this week.
+
#::*Held our second of two webinars on using recreational drones for STEM on April 26. ~25 participants.
#** Held our first Webinar, Using Recreational Drones for STEM, on March 22: We had 37 very engaged participants
+
#::*14 of our 15 workshop slots were snapped up within a day of the second Webinar. We'll cap registration at 20.
#** Our pre-webinar survey indicates that participants are interested in using recreational drones to gather data, and also to learn about how drones are used in professional settings. The most frequent answer about how they hope to use drones for learning is in after-school clubs. Also, participants identified "sufficient professional development" as the thing that would motivate them most to begin using drones for teaching and learning.
+
#::*Our strategic plan was finalized and posted.
#** Next Webinar is two weeks from Today: April 26 @ 4 PM EDT. Title is Plan, Fly, Review: Documenting Drone Data.
 
 
#* IT&I
 
#* IT&I
#** Rich Signell (USGS / WHOI) has accepted the IT&I co-chair position.  
+
#**[http://wiki.esipfed.org/index.php/Interoperability_and_Technology/Rants_And_Raves_Webinar_Series Tech Dive webinars ]
#** Moving forward starting in April, IT&I is combining USGS Tech Stack and ESIP IT&I R&R webinar series into IT&I Tech Dive Talks. Next two "[[Interoperability_and_Technology/Tech_Dive_Webinar_Series|Tech Dive]]" Webinars scheduled (formerly "Rants and Raves")
+
#*** May Tech Dive this Thursday on Leaflet.Timeseries
 +
#*** June Tech Dive next month on Docker
 +
#*** April Tech Dive Webinar was on GeoPlatform.gov
 
#* Nominations
 
#* Nominations
#** Stay tuned for example P&P document
+
#::*Added our suggestions/lessons learned to the [[List_of_Polices_and_Procedures | Policies and Procedures]] listing, and added a category tag of "PoliciesAndProcedures" (this tag can be changed, but I thought it was a good idea to start with something)
 +
#::*Waiting on discussion with ESIP President about establishing the next NomCom chair and committee
 
#* Products & Services
 
#* Products & Services
#** Developing guidelines for RFPs (with ExCom and Semantic Tech) and Testbed privacy and evaluations.
+
#::*Released the [http://testbed.esipfed.org/node/9169 Spring 2016 RFP].
#** Continuing to look for participants for the software evaluation effort, will be discussing possible collaboration with Software Carpentry and working with EarthCube on a related assessment workshop.
+
#::*Drafting ESIP Testbed and RFP [[List_of_Polices_and_Procedures | Policies and Procedures]]
 +
#::*Co-organizing an ESIP/EarthCube Software Assessment Workshop (June, Boulder, CO) and will provide report out from that activity as well as incorporate assessment feedback into the ESIP software evaluation guidelines as part of that ongoing activity.
 
#* Semantic Technology
 
#* Semantic Technology
#** Working on an ESIP-wide resource for semantic technology deployment
+
#::*In the process of evaluating community needs for an ontology portal. Currently drafting an [http://wiki.esipfed.org/index.php/Semantic_Web_Ontology_Portal_Evaluation_Approach Evaluation Plan].
#** Working on an ESIP-wide evaluation/tutorial on ontologies and semantics with likely hands-on eval at summer meeting
+
#::*Beginning the process of migrating semantic resources to the cloud
#** Working with Products & Services and software group to re-use/extend evaluation and reuse metrics
+
#::*Mid-term goal is to better quantify what community really needs and what infrastructure is required to support this
 
# Type Rep Reports  
 
# Type Rep Reports  
#* Type I  
+
#* Type I - Continuing to map between ESIP Type I, CDF, COPDESS, re3data, and WDS registries. Goal to show results at Summer Meeting, likely in a Friday morning session.
#** Continuing to gather and compare information on registries (ESIP Type I, EarthCube CDF, WDS/DSA, COPDESS, re3data.org). Will discuss at the COPDESS meeting at EGU on 04/21, specifically 1) how to create links between repository profiles, and 2) which statements/accords the repository has endorsed.  
+
#* Type II  
#* Type II - No report
+
#* Type III - Met May 5 for first Type 3 telecon. Small, but productive call. Organizing a type gathering at ESIP Summer and hope to have a more formal activity at the Winter Meeting.
#* Type III - No report
+
# Other Business
# Other Business - No other business
+
#* GEO Program Committee Report - Kathy
 +
#* Member Map - Christine/Annie B - This idea sprouted during our April Sponsor meetings, when a sponsor asked about the spatial distribution of ESIP members. Annie is working with the existing ESIP member data for an initial visualization of where members are located; also, in the spirit of Science Communication, she is researching different map styles to share and visualize other ESIP stories
 +
#* Creative ways to crowdsource RFIs?
 +
#* Any other business?

Revision as of 16:43, May 31, 2016

Attendees
Emily Law, President
Danie Kinkade, Chair, Partnership
Ken Keiser, Chair, C&B
Bob Arko, Type I Rep
Ted Habermann, Type III Rep
LuAnn Dahlman, Chair, Education
Ethan Davis, Chair, IT & I
Justin Goldstein, Chair, Data Stewardship
Soren Scott, Chair, P & S
Erin Robinson, Staff
Annie Burgess, Staff
Rebecca Fowler, Staff

Mintes

  1. Approval of April Minutes
    • Bill Teng motioned to approve the April Minutes and LuAnn Dahlman seconded. The Minutes were approved by acclamation.
  2. President's Report
    • Highlight
      • The Foundation for Earth Science: FES board meeting was held on April 29, 2016. It covered ESIP report (sponsors visit, summer meeting, endorsement of “Open Data in Big Data World”, ESIP evaluation), Foundation/ESIP organization structure update, finance report and ESIP Director report (proposals, letter of collaboration, staff update and training, near term activities).
      • Open, Public, Electronic and Necessary (OPEN) Government Data Act: The Center for Data Innovation (CDI) was seeking co-signers in their letter of support for this legislation to be introduced into the U.S. House and Senate. Upon reviewing the proposed legislation and summary, the FES board members unanimously voted in favor to support this bill. The proposal, summary and support letter can be found at: https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/0B_2czh6FTo34OE1HTWE1OXlodk0. CDI published a press release regarding the letter of support.
    • FYI
      • JPL new leadership: Michael M. Watkins, the Clare Cockrell Williams Centennial Chair in Aerospace Engineering and Director of the Center for Space Research at The University of Texas at Austin, and a former leader at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, has been appointed to serve as Director of JPL and Vice President at Caltech effective July 1, 2016.
  3. Staff Report
    • Highlights
      • Erin - Evaluation is going well. Interviews are in progress and survey questions need review. Survey will go out next week. Last quarter was a heavy fundraising/proposal writing quarter. We submitted two proposals for basic ESIP support + Testbed work, co-I on three NSF proposals that would utilize ESIP framework and wrote 9 letters of support. Confirmed two of three plenary speakers - Ben Preston, ORNL, Ellen Prager, Earth2Ocean and Jon Marino (To Be Confirmed).
      • Annie B. - Working on membership database; Next round of evaluation testbed will kick-off in July; Summer Meeting draft schedule is posted.
      • Rebecca - Developing a Communication Strategy; AGU Data Blog (looking for contributing authors); Led development of 2015 Annual Report - feedback welcome.
      • Dan - Migrated ESIP to GoToMeeting; Working on the ImHere Check-in System. This is ready for use on ESIP telecons to begin familiarizing with tool.
      • Annie K. - Recovering well! Back to work on Summer Meeting logistics.
    • Actions:
  4. Committee Reports
    • C&B
    • Finance
    • Starting to draft process documents, based on our discussion notes over the past year, to be included in C&B's policies and procedures (P&P) wiki page.
    • Will hold an informal Ficom meeting at ESIP Summer.
    • Either together with this meeting or separately, will make Ficom available to any group planning to submit a budget for FY17.
    • For discussion: Excom (I think) has discussed the possibility of scheduling an informal session at ESIP Summer for those groups that got funding for FY16 to give a short report.
    • Partnership
      • Reviewed, vetted and posted five new membership applications: Geospatialmetadata.com, Cyber Infrastructure Research and Development Lab for Earth Sciences (CIRDLES), Open Geospatial Consortium, Ronin Institutue, and EarthCube. Posting of last application went up on 22 April, will be viewed for 30days for comment, then move on to voting by Assembly. Next meeting will focus on review and update of new member packet in time for new member distribution; to include addition of welcome letter from Emily, and completion of 'code of conduct' drafted by previous committee.
    • Data Stewardship
    • During the April monthly meeting, Data Stewardship Committee member, Ge Peng, provided a progress report regarding the work on Data Stewardship Maturity Matrix (DSMM). The key highlights included the current structure of the DSMM as well as the pilot program that was being conducted at the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) in order to demonstrate the utility and establish baselines for DSMM in the NCEI environment/context. Peng also shared that there would be two DSMM related sessions at the ESIP 2016 Summer Meeting. In addtion to Peng's updates on the DSMM, the Data Stewardship Committee also had a guest speaker, Jon Jablonski, from the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB). Jon is the Head of Map & Image Laboratory at UCSB, and his presentation discussed the types of geographic information system and spatial data services that are being provided at UCSB. Finally, before concluding the meeting, Committee member, Ruth Duerr, shared with the meeting attendees regarding the Data Citation and Attribution in Linguistics (https://sites.google.com/a/hawaii.edu/data-citation/workshop2) Workshop she attended. Ruth felt the group might have the potential to be the Coalition for Publishing Data in the Earth and Space Sciences (COPDESS) for the linguistic discipline.
    • Education
    • Held our second of two webinars on using recreational drones for STEM on April 26. ~25 participants.
    • 14 of our 15 workshop slots were snapped up within a day of the second Webinar. We'll cap registration at 20.
    • Our strategic plan was finalized and posted.
    • IT&I
      • Tech Dive webinars
        • May Tech Dive this Thursday on Leaflet.Timeseries
        • June Tech Dive next month on Docker
        • April Tech Dive Webinar was on GeoPlatform.gov
    • Nominations
    • Added our suggestions/lessons learned to the Policies and Procedures listing, and added a category tag of "PoliciesAndProcedures" (this tag can be changed, but I thought it was a good idea to start with something)
    • Waiting on discussion with ESIP President about establishing the next NomCom chair and committee
    • Products & Services
    • Released the Spring 2016 RFP.
    • Drafting ESIP Testbed and RFP Policies and Procedures
    • Co-organizing an ESIP/EarthCube Software Assessment Workshop (June, Boulder, CO) and will provide report out from that activity as well as incorporate assessment feedback into the ESIP software evaluation guidelines as part of that ongoing activity.
    • Semantic Technology
    • In the process of evaluating community needs for an ontology portal. Currently drafting an Evaluation Plan.
    • Beginning the process of migrating semantic resources to the cloud
    • Mid-term goal is to better quantify what community really needs and what infrastructure is required to support this
  5. Type Rep Reports
    • Type I - Continuing to map between ESIP Type I, CDF, COPDESS, re3data, and WDS registries. Goal to show results at Summer Meeting, likely in a Friday morning session.
    • Type II
    • Type III - Met May 5 for first Type 3 telecon. Small, but productive call. Organizing a type gathering at ESIP Summer and hope to have a more formal activity at the Winter Meeting.
  6. Other Business
    • GEO Program Committee Report - Kathy
    • Member Map - Christine/Annie B - This idea sprouted during our April Sponsor meetings, when a sponsor asked about the spatial distribution of ESIP members. Annie is working with the existing ESIP member data for an initial visualization of where members are located; also, in the spirit of Science Communication, she is researching different map styles to share and visualize other ESIP stories
    • Creative ways to crowdsource RFIs?
    • Any other business?